“The struggle against Zionism has nothing in common with antisemitism. Zionism is the enemy of the working people of the whole world, both of Jews and of non-Jews.” - Joseph Stalin


This distinction is not a modern invention or a convenient slogan. It is rooted in a long history of anti-colonial and anti-imperialist thought. Today, as the people of Gaza continue to endure the consequences of Israeli military operations, territorial control, and severe humanitarian restrictions more than a year after a fragile ceasefire took effect, the quote retains urgent relevance. Opposition to the policies pursued by the Israeli state in Gaza is not hatred of Jews. It is resistance to what many around the world correctly identify as collective punishment, occupation, and the denial of basic rights. The practices that anti-fascists have always been duty-bound to confront.


Stalin’s formulation, reported in the Soviet military newspaper “Krasnaya Zvezda” in 1953, reflected the official Soviet position that Zionism constituted a form of bourgeois nationalism aligned with Western imperialism. The Soviet Union had not always held this view consistently. In the late 1940s, Moscow supported the United Nations partition plan for Palestine and recognized the new State of Israel, calculating that a Jewish state might weaken British influence in the Middle East and possibly tilt toward the socialist camp. That calculation collapsed once Israel aligned firmly with the United States. What followed was a sharp turn toward anti-Zionist policy, both internationally and inside the USSR.


Inside the Soviet Union, this shift coincided with the dissolution of the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee, the arrest and execution of many of its leading members in 1952, the campaign against “rootless cosmopolitans,” and the notorious Doctors’ Plot of 1952–53. Historians continue to debate the precise mix of political calculation, personal prejudice, and Cold War paranoia that drove these events. What is not in dispute is that the Soviet state repeatedly insisted publicly and in its official ideology that its opposition was directed at Zionism as a political movement and not at Jews as a people. Stalin himself had earlier issued one of the strongest official condemnations of antisemitism on record, describing it in 1931 as “the most dangerous vestige of cannibalism” and a tool used by exploiters to divide the working class.


The insistence on separating anti-Zionism from antisemitism was not unique to the Soviet experience. It has been a consistent theme in anti-colonial movements across the Global South and among progressive forces that supported Palestinian self-determination. The claim that any criticism of Israeli state policy is automatically antisemitic has long served a political purpose to place the actions of a powerful, nuclear-armed state beyond the reach of ordinary moral and political scrutiny.


That claim is being tested again in Gaza. The conflict that began with the Hamas-led attacks of 7 October 2023 has produced a catastrophic human toll. Gaza health authorities, whose figures are widely treated as reliable by United Nations agencies, have reported more than 74,000 Palestinians killed and over 175,000 injured since the start of the war. Even after the ceasefire that took effect in October 2025, Israeli forces have continued operations that have killed more than 1,600 additional people, according to the same sources. Large areas of the Strip remain under direct or indirect Israeli military control. The so-called Yellow Line, originally presented as a temporary demarcation, has expanded, confining the overwhelming majority of Gaza’s 2.1 million residents to a shrinking fraction of the territory. Aid flows have been repeatedly restricted. Reconstruction has barely begun. Hundreds of thousands remain displaced, living in tents or damaged buildings amid ongoing shortages of food, water, medicine, and shelter.


These are not abstract statistics. They describe a population subjected to sustained military pressure, severe movement restrictions, and a humanitarian crisis that human rights organizations have documented in detail. To describe this reality, to demand an end to the killing of civilians, the lifting of restrictions on aid, and the recognition of Palestinian rights, is not an expression of ethnic hatred. It is the elementary duty of anyone who claims to stand against fascism, collective punishment, and the abuse of overwhelming military power.
Fascism, in its classical and modern forms, has always rested on the dehumanization of an entire people, the use of overwhelming force against civilians, and the equation of dissent with existential threat. When Israeli officials and their most fervent supporters treat every demand for accountability as proof of antisemitism, they invert the historical meaning of the term. Antisemitism is the hatred of Jews as Jews. Anti-Zionism, as articulated in the Stalin quotation and in decades of progressive tradition, is opposition to a specific political project and to the policies carried out in its name. Conflating the two does not protect Jewish people; it shields state power from criticism and empties the word “antisemitism” of its precise and necessary meaning.
History shows that genuine anti-fascism requires clarity. It requires the ability to distinguish between a people and the policies of a government, between legitimate self-determination and expansionist control, between the memory of past persecution and the present reality of overwhelming force applied to a trapped civilian population. The working people of the world - Jewish and non-Jewish have no interest in the perpetual subjugation of another people. They have every interest in ending the cycle of violence, occupation, and collective suffering that has defined Gaza for years.


It is a reminder that the political struggle against a particular form of nationalism and state power need not, and must not, be reduced to racial animus. In the face of Gaza’s continuing devastation, that distinction remains both accurate and necessary. Those who refuse to draw it are not defending the victims of history. They are protecting the architects of the present.